BYU Cougars

Can the Big 12 Get Three Teams Into the College Football Playoff? Here’s What Needs to Happen

Jan 8, 2024; Houston, TX, USA; A view of the CFP Trophy before the 2024 College Football Playoff national championship game between the Michigan Wolverines and the Washington Huskies at NRG Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Can the Big 12 get three teams into the College Football Playoff? With one week remaining in the regular season, Utah, Texas Tech and BYU all remain in the hunt, but getting all three into the 12-team field will require some help.

Utah is undefeated at 11-0 and has already clinched a spot in the Big 12 Championship Game. Texas Tech is 10-1, while BYU sits at 9-2 following its triple-overtime victory over Kansas.

All three entered Week 12 ranked in the College Football Playoff Top 12, giving the Big 12 a legitimate opportunity to secure multiple playoff bids.

But can the conference actually get three?

Where Utah, Texas Tech and BYU Stand in the CFP Rankings

Here are the three Big 12 contenders in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, released November 17.

TeamCFP RankingRecord
UtahNo. 211-0
BYUNo. 109-2
Texas TechNo. 1210-1

The rankings above are from November 17, while the records reflect results through Week 12. The next CFP rankings will be released Tuesday, November 24.

Under the 2026 playoff format, the Big 12 champion receives an automatic bid. The other two contenders would need to earn at-large spots.

Utah’s College Football Playoff Path

Utah is in the strongest position of any Big 12 team.

The Utes have already secured a trip to Arlington and remain undefeated after beating TCU 38-17. They are the only undefeated team left in the FBS.

A victory over West Virginia in Week 13 would give Utah a perfect 12-0 regular season, strengthening its case for a first-round bye.

Even if Utah loses the Big 12 Championship Game, the Utes would have a compelling argument for an at-large selection based on their overall résumé.

Utah is not mathematically guaranteed a playoff spot yet, but its position is exceptionally strong.

Texas Tech’s College Football Playoff Path

Texas Tech controls its own destiny in the Big 12 Championship race.

The Red Raiders need only defeat TCU on Thanksgiving night to secure a trip to Arlington, where they would face Utah.

Winning the conference championship would guarantee Texas Tech a CFP berth.

However, the more interesting question is whether the Red Raiders could make the playoff without winning the Big 12.

Texas Tech entered Week 12 ranked No. 12, just outside the projected playoff field because of the automatic qualifying spots. Had the college football season ended last week, Texas Tech would have been the First Team Out of the CFP.

A win over TCU followed by a competitive loss to Utah would leave Texas Tech at 11-2, but the selection committee would still have to decide whether that résumé deserves an at-large bid. Frankly, unless it was a razor-thin loss to Utah, it seems unlikely Texas Tech, with a weaker Strength of Schedule and underwhelming non-conference slate would make the CFP in this scenario.

Missing the Big 12 Championship Game entirely would all but guarantee the Red Raiders to miss the CFP.

BYU’s College Football Playoff Path

BYU might have the most fascinating situation of the three contenders.

The Cougars entered Week 12 ranked No. 10 in the CFP rankings and improved to 9-2 after surviving Kansas in triple overtime.

However, BYU needs to beat Cincinnati and have Texas Tech lose to TCU to reach the Big 12 Championship Game.

You can find the full breakdown in our Big 12 Championship Game scenarios for Week 13.

If BYU beats Cincinnati but misses the conference title game, the Cougars would finish 10-2 and could make a strong argument for an at-large bid.

BYU’s résumé includes a victory over Notre Dame and a narrow loss to Utah, two results that could matter significantly when the committee compares bubble teams.

In fact, reaching the Big 12 Championship Game and losing could potentially hurt BYU’s at-large chances by giving the Cougars a third defeat.

If I was Kalani Sitake, I’d take my chances and prefer to not make the Big 12 Championship Game, and roll with a 10-2 resume into Selection Sunday. That Notre Dame win is incredibly valuable, and thus far, the committee has rewarded it in its rankings.

What Needs to Happen for Three Big 12 Teams to Make the CFP?

The most favorable scenario for three Big 12 playoff teams would involve Utah, Texas Tech and BYU all winning their regular-season finales.

That would leave Utah at 12-0, Texas Tech at 11-1 and BYU at 10-2.

Utah and Texas Tech would then meet in the Big 12 Championship Game, while BYU would wait for an at-large selection.

The Big 12 champion would receive an automatic bid. The championship-game loser and BYU would both need the committee to select them.

The Best-Case Scenario I see right now: Texas Tech upsets undefeated Utah in the Big 12 Championship Game, while BYU’s 10-2 resume remains strong with the Notre Dame win to sneak three teams into the CFP.

For that to happen, the Big 12 would likely need favorable results elsewhere, including losses by competing at-large contenders in the SEC, Big Ten, ACC and among independents.

The bottom line: Three Big 12 teams making the College Football Playoff is possible, but two bids remain a more realistic outcome.

The next CFP rankings on Tuesday will offer a clearer picture of how much room Utah, Texas Tech and BYU have entering the final weekend of the regular season.

Most Popular

To Top